Founder Self-Evaluation: Farmer Economics - *The ₹32/Day Profit Nightmare*
(Why Your "Doubling Incomes" Pitch Fails When 83% of Farmers Can’t Afford Seeds Next Season)
PART 1: FACTOR INTRODUCTION
1.1 The Vicious Cycle of Indian Farmer Economics
Diagram
Code
2023 Ground Realities (NABARD Data):
Metric Small Farmer (<2Ha) Large Farmer (>10Ha)
Avg. Income ₹6,800/month ₹23,500/month
Input Costs 68% of revenue 42% of revenue
Debt Burden 82% indebted 47% indebted
Profit/Day ₹32 ₹420
1.2 Startup Blindspots:
1. The MSP Illusion:
o Only 6% farmers benefit from MSP (Wheat/Rice in Punjab/Haryana)
2. Credit Reality:
o 78% loans come from informal sources at 24-36% interest (sahukars, not banks)
3. Profit ≠ Income:
o A Punjab farmer’s ₹10L annual revenue ≠ ₹10L profit (₹7L goes to inputs/interest)
1.3 Founder Trap: "Assuming farmers will pay premiums for ‘sustainability’ when they’re choosing between urea and daughters’ school fees."
________________________________________
PART 2: FARMER ECONOMICS CASE STUDIES
1. The Debt Slayer (➕);Case: "KisanMitra* (MP) increased profits by:
1. Input Financing: Advanced seeds/fertilizers at 12% interest (vs sahukar’s 30%)
2. Crop Swaps: Shifted 1,200 farmers from cotton to pigeon pea (30% lower input costs)
3. Collective Bargaining: Pooled harvests to bypass arthiyas
Result: Avg. profit rose from ₹18/day to ₹210/day in 3 years."*
Lesson: "Fix debt first, then talk tech."
2. The Yield Obsession Failure (➖);Case: *"A agtech startup pushed high-yield paddy in Odisha:
1. Farmers took ₹50K loans for HYV seeds
2. Monsoon failed → 100% crop loss
3. 14 farmers sold land to repay debts
*Startup folded after suicide backlash."
Bloody Lesson: "Yield ≠ Prosperity when debt lurks."
3. The Grey Market Survivor (➗);Case: "BlackSoil Farms* (Telangana) thrives by:
1. Letting farmers grow ganja as cash crop (hidden between cotton)
2. Using illicit profits to fund legal crops
3. Laundering money via "organic exports"
Cold Truth: "When formal systems fail, parallel economies flourish."
________________________________________
PART 3: SELF-ASSESSMENT (THEORY VS. DIRTY HANDS)
3.1 Context Check
"Which farmer reality have you faced?"
• Debt Slayer: We’ve improved real incomes
• Yield Obsessed: Burnt by input-cost spirals
• Grey Participant: Working system hacks
• Still Talking About "Doubling Incomes"
3.2 Impact Rating
"How much have you actually moved farmer profits?"
[-5 = Deepened Debt │ 0 = No Impact │ +5 = 200%+ Income Growth]
3.3 Knowledge Depth
"How well do you really understand farmer economics?"
1. ☐ Spreadsheet-Level (Know theory)
2. ☐ Field-Level (See loan sharks in action)
3. ☐ Jugaad-Level (Created workarounds)
4. ☐ Debt Reformer (Restructured 100+ loans)
5. ☐ Profit Yodha (Your farmers beat arthiya margins)
3.4 Gap Analysis
"Improving farmer economics would mostly help us:"
• Ensure Supply (Farmers stick with us)
• Boost Margins (Shared prosperity)
• Both
3.5 Priority Call
"Where does farmer profitability sit on your aaj ka loan vs kal ka fayda list?"
• 🔴 Hai-Hai! (Our model worsens debt)
• 🟢 Goldmine! (Our farmers prosper → loyalty)
• 🟡 Chalta Hai (Not our focus)
• ⚪ Relevant Nahi (We don’t work with farmers)
3.6 Decision Audit *(For scores ≤-3 or ≥4)*
"Describe one farmer economics pivot:"
Example: "We stopped pushing organic certs after realizing farmers needed cash, not premiums."
3.7 Key Gyaan (100 Characters Max)
"One kisaan truth about economics we’d carve on our HQ wall:"
(E.g., "No agtech matters until harvest pays more than debt")
________________________________________
Farmer Realities Most Miss
1. The Kharif-Rabi Trap:
o 68% take kharif loans hoping rabi will repay → monsoon fails → cycle continues
2. Gender Debt:
o Women farmers pay 8% higher interest (no land titles as collateral)
3. Policy Irony:
o Loan waivers increase informal borrowing (banks stop lending to "risky" farmers)
________________________________________
Why This Module Cuts Deeper
1. Exposes "Income" Myths: ₹10L revenue ≠ ₹10L profit
2. Spotlights Debt Realities: 24% informal interest rates crush all innovation
3. Forces Tradeoff Awareness: Sustainability ≠ Survival for 83% farmers
Next macro-factor? We’ll strip bare more rural economic truths.
(Style Note: Using Hinglish like aaj ka loan for gut-level impact – specify if formal English preferred.)
